top of page
Writer's picturePaola M. Urteaga

Growth vs Fixed Mindset: Navigating Challenges with Confidence

Updated: Oct 18, 2024



Unlock your leadership potential by mastering the skills that drive success— from emotional intelligence to adaptability. Embrace a growth mindset and confidently navigate challenges"


Many of us find ourselves in roles that feel restrictive and toxic. We recognize our potential but often feel stifled in our current situations. Breaking through these barriers is less about escaping the job itself and more about shifting how we perceive ourselves and our capabilities. As a business coach, I frequently meet clients at a crossroads, frustrated with their roles. Just last week, one client found herself overwhelmed by a micromanaging boss. After receiving a promotion and a raise, she felt even more pressure. Our journey explored a critical mindset shift that helped her regain confidence and control. Instead of resigning immediately, we uncovered potential reasons behind the managerial changes and empowered her to engage with her boss constructively, seeking to learn from the situation rather than flee.


What is a Growth Mindset? 


A growth mindset is built on the belief that intelligence, talent, and abilities can be developed with effort, learning, and perseverance. Psychologist Carol Dweck popularized this idea, showing that people with a growth mindset view challenges as opportunities to learn. Failure, rather than being a reflection of one’s worth, becomes a stepping stone to success. Leaders with a growth mindset foster resilience, innovation, and adaptability within their teams. They encourage feedback, embrace challenges, and use setbacks as learning experiences.

In leadership, a growth mindset helps develop a team culture where innovation is encouraged, and employees feel safe to take calculated risks. Leaders who promote this mindset don’t simply accept mistakes—they encourage learning from them. This approach builds stronger, more adaptive teams that thrive under pressure.


What is a Fixed Mindset? 


A fixed mindset operates on the belief that talent and intelligence are static traits, unable to evolve. Individuals with this mindset see failure as a reflection of their worth and often avoid risks or challenges to maintain their perceived competence. In the workplace, this can manifest as reluctance to take on new responsibilities or fear of innovation, stifling both personal and organizational growth.


In my client’s case, the fixed mindset showed up when she assumed her boss's controlling behavior would remain unchanged. She believed her only option was to leave. However, as we explored her assumptions, we found that her manager’s new approach stemmed from external pressures—factors she hadn’t initially considered. This shift in understanding allowed her to reframe the situation and approach it with a more growth-oriented mindset.


False Growth Mindset 


A false growth mindset occurs when individuals or organizations claim to adopt a growth mindset but fail to implement its core principles genuinely. It’s easy to fall into the trap of praising effort without considering the quality of outcomes or equating constant busyness with progress. Carol Dweck highlights that a true growth mindset requires reflection, learning from mistakes, and adjusting strategies for meaningful development.


In leadership, false growth mindset can lead to complacency, where employees receive recognition for effort without critical feedback on how to improve. Leaders need to cultivate not just persistence but an environment that fosters real progress. My client had to navigate this herself—her boss praised her efforts but failed to provide actionable feedback, leaving her feeling stuck despite her hard work.


Examples of Toxicity Beyond Micromanagement 


In addition to micromanagement, toxic environments can present in other forms, including:


  1. Blame Culture: In organizations where finger-pointing is common, employees often fear speaking up, knowing mistakes are met with harsh consequences rather than opportunities for growth.

  2. Lack of Transparency: When leaders withhold information or keep employees in the dark about key decisions, it creates distrust and erodes team morale, further deepening workplace toxicity.


These dynamics can be just as debilitating as micromanagement, preventing employees from feeling empowered and contributing fully to their roles.


Actionable Strategies to Embrace a Growth Mindset


  1. Embrace Challenges: Rather than avoiding difficult situations, view them as opportunities to grow and develop new skills. Even if you fail, the process of tackling a challenge is valuable for your personal growth.

  2. Accept Failure as Part of Learning: Understand that failure is not an end but a necessary part of the learning process. Reflect on what didn’t work, and use those lessons to improve your future efforts.

  3. Seek Constructive Feedback: Don’t hesitate to ask for feedback from colleagues, mentors, or managers. Growth isn’t just about working hard—it’s about working smarter by learning from others’ insights.


Unlocking Your Leadership Potential with a Growth Mindset

Mindset is a powerful tool in achieving success. Whether navigating the corporate landscape or starting your own venture, adopting a growth mindset can radically change how you approach challenges, handle failure, and engage in continuous learning. My client’s journey is just one example of how shifting from a fixed mindset to a growth mindset brings clarity, confidence, and resilience to face difficult situations head-on.


If you ever feel stuck in your career or business, assess your mindset. Are you holding yourself back with limiting beliefs, or are you ready to adapt, learn, and grow? Remember, the path to success isn’t about perfection; it’s about continuous improvement. By nurturing a growth mindset, you open yourself up to a world of endless possibilities.


References


  1. Dweck, C. S. (2006). Mindset: The New Psychology of Success. New York: Random House.

  2. Dweck, C. S. (2015). The False Growth Mindset. Retrieved from Harvard Business Review

  3. Mindset Works. (n.d.). Growth Mindset Resources and Assessments. Retrieved from Mindset Works

  4. Positive Psychology. (n.d.). Growth Mindset Assessment Tools. Retrieved from Positive Psychology

  5. Sinek, S. (2009). Start With Why: How Great Leaders Inspire Everyone to Take Action. New York: Portfolio.


Bình luận


bottom of page